Some wineries are like the show “The Family Guy”: you never know if you’re in for 30 minutes of awesome or 30 minutes of awkward gags that don’t quite land. A winery with which we’ve had this sort of relationship is Potomac Point Vineyard and Winery. We’re adventurous, so we rolled up to see what was shaking this time around.
As always, the tasting room was busy, but this time around the service was pretty good. It wasn’t long before we got our first pour: the 2010 La Belle Vie Rose ($16.99). This rose is a blend of 80% Syrah and 20% Chambourcin with 1% residual sugar. I found the nose to be funky and fruity, and it was generally a basic deck-type wine. The 2011 Chardonnay ($15.99) was described to us as a stainless steel chard with 15% of Viognier blended in. For a stainless wine, I was getting a bit of butter and vanilla on the nose, along with a fuller mouthfeel. It wasn’t bad, but it certainly didn’t have the crispness that I look for in a stainless chard.
We were then poured an off-list wine, a 2009 Chardonnay Reserve (no price given). It was buttery and oaky and generic. The 2010 Chardonnay Reserve ($21.99) was better, more interesting with some green olive notes. The chards were followed by the 2010 Viognier Reserve ($24.99), a stainless steel viggy with 10% 0f chardonnay blended in. The tasting notes indicated banana accents and they weren’t kidding. It came through strongly on the nose and palate, sort of like the banana Now & Laters you keep letting slide to the bottom of the candy bowl. There were other tropical fruits in there, but… nanners. For sure.
We headed for the sweeter side, beginning with the Custom Label White Sweet ($13.99), a blend of Sauvignon Blanc, Vidal Blanc, and Petit Manseng at 2% residual sugar. It had that sweet/floral vidal nose and was sweet and flat on the palate. Meh. The 2010 La Belle Vie White ($12.99) was more enjoyable for me. This blend of Vidal Blanc, Viognier, Chardonnay, and Petit Manseng (1.5% residual sugar) showed lime and citrus without cloying sweetness. To the reds!
The first red we tried was the 2010 Abbinato ($16.99), a 50-50 blend of Sangiovese and Touriga Nacional. This is a wine that typifies my relationship with Potomac Point. I did not like the 2008 vintage of this wine. Here’s how I reacted to the 2009 vintage: ” I loved this wine to a bizarre degree. I didn’t just want to bring a bottle home, I wanted to adopt it, send it to college, and buy it a house.” Seriously, we were digging it. The 2010? Not so much. It had a nice nose but it was thin and watery and… not special.
We were next poured the 2009 Cabernet Franc ($22.99). It was a very plain Jane cab franc, and for some odd reason they served a chocolate with it. I often disagree with the “here have a chocolate with this wine cuz it’s red,” but it REALLY did nothing for the wine (and vice versa). Plus, we were nowhere near done, so I was desperately scrubbing the chocolate from my palate so I could taste the Custom Label Red ($20.99). This was a blend of Merlot, Cabernet Franc, and Cabernet Sauvignon. There was a less than enjoyable funk on the nose and the palate had the merest flash of berry and.. nothing.
Potomac Point then flirted with a lawsuit from the Meritage Alliance with their 2009 Heritage ($26.99), a Bordeaux style blend of Merlot, Cabernet Franc, Cabernet Sauvignon, and Petit Verdot. It was surprisingly light for a not-a-Meritage, with indistinct fruit and not much happening, The reds wrapped up with the 2009 Petit Verdot ($24.99). The nose was full of rich, dark fruit that just didn’t seem to translate to the palate.
We finished the tasting with two sweeter wines. The first was the 2010 Vin de Paille ($26.99 for a 375mL), a rich dessert wine made from 65% Late Harvest Vidal Blanc, 30% Late Harvest Petit Manseng, and 5% Muscat Raisin with 16.8% alcohol and 12.5% residual sugar. I enjoyed this one. Imagine multiplying the honeyed richness of a “regular” late harvest wine by the number of bad movies Nicholas Cage has made. Mmmm.
The final wine was the 2010 Rabelos Port ($39.99 for a 750 mL), 50% Touriga/ 30% Chambourcin/ 20% Tinto Cao aged in bourbon barrels for 17.5% alcohol and 9% residual sugar. On the palate, I got the smoky wood of the barrel, then the rich dark fruit, then the booze. It wasn’t harsh, but it wasn’t as integrated as I might have hoped for.
Potomac Point has a pretty space, and when the wines are on point (see what I did there?) they can be quite good. My quibble is just that they’re not really consistent.