Sometimes when you taste a wine, you just note that you like it and want to take it home. Other times you may think of a particular person with whom you want to share the bottle. At still other times, you taste a wine and think of a specific food pairing. The last was definitely the case when I tasted the ’09 Church Creek Steel Chardonnay from Chatham Vineyards when we visited the Eastern Shore with some fellow VA wine bloggers last summer. I immediately thought of scallops! We finally had fresh scallops and the foresight to chill this bottle of wine on the same night, so we got to see if my instinct was good.
The wine offered a crisp lemon and apple nose with a lot of great acid on the palate. Lemon was definitely the dominant flavor, and this let it pair amazingly well with the grilled scallops that Grape Envy Guy has perfected (thanks to some help from Cooks Illustrated).
In this case, my food pairing instinct was pretty safe – after all, a steel chard and fish isn’t a crazy, unheard of idea. That said, the strong lemon notes in this wine made it a particularly welcome pairing with the scallops, and the grilled scallops ended up being just creamy enough to balance out the acid in the wine.
All in all, I’d say this is a winner of a wine, and if you get the chance to pick up a bottle, do so – at least if you like some bright acid in your whites.